This is the third volume in Frank McCourt autobiography and follows the award winning Angela's Ashes and 'Tis. It tells the tale of McCourt becoming a teacher in New York and later a writer.
He misquotes Pope: "Know thyself, presume not God to scan/ The proper study of mankind is man" (Pope's version is Know then thyself ...).
He is very eloquent about teaching in his usual rhythmic 'I am Irish' style. There are moments which are funny and moments which are interesting but I didn't catch my breath until McCourt the teacher is interrogating a rich kid in his creative writing class about his dinner. He asks who cooked it. The maid. And served it. He asks about the table - mahogany - and the chandelier and the music. Not Mozart. Telemann. "He's one of my father's favourites," says the student. And where is your father? Then comes the brutal pay-off line: "He's in Sloan-Kettering Hospital with lung cancer and my mother is with him all he time because he's expected to die."
Instantly the world of privilege of the spoilt little rich kid dissolves into a world of despair and a little kid.
Every teacher has had a moment like that. Mine was when I asked, rhetorically, what Sabir's mother would say if she found out what he had done to be told, through tears, that his mother wouldn't say a word because her windpipe had been crushed in a car accident and it was still uncertain whether she would survive. I put my arm around Sabir and hugged him till the tears subsided.
Although at the start of the book I thought it was McCourt churning out the old Irish brogue formula that powered his previous two books (but Angela's Ashes rather more than 'Tis), when he started describing his Creative Writing classes at Stuyvesant High and the unusual (bizarre!) strategies he adopted (eg getting the students to sing recipes) his love of teaching and his characterisation of the kids he taught caught me and held me in a magical enchantment. By the end I loved the book.
December 2011; 258 pages
Other memoirs reviewed in this blog can be found here.
- Strumpet City by James Plunkett: a book about the poor in Dublin in the early 20th Century
- Teacher Man by Frank McCourt: the sequel to Angela's Ashes: an Irish exile in New York
- Dubliners by James Joyce: the classic short stories
- Castle Rackrent by Maria Edgworth: a classic first published in 1800
- Paddy Clarke Ha Ha Ha by Roddy Doyle: a boy grows up in Ireland
- The Spinning Heart by Donal Ryan: set in the recession of the early 21st Century
No comments:
Post a Comment