"The Rainbow" by D H Lawrence

This rainbow soars over a housing estate nowadays, but the built arch was the doorway to a foundry which produced, among other things, a steam plough for Garibaldi.

 This novel was published in 1915. It is a multi-generational family saga.

There are multiple religious themes. 

• Will Brangwen, when courting Anna, is carving wood to show the Creation of Eve: God stoops over a sleeping Adam  and Eve "was issuing like a flame towards the hand of God, from the torn side of Adam." (Ch 4) But once he is married, he cannot continue with the work. Anna jeers at it: “It is impudence to say that Woman was made out of Man's body ... when every man is born of woman.” (Ch 6) So he burns it.
• When newlywed Will is enjoying an extended honeymoon, lying in bed with Anna in their new home, he feels "as though this house was the Ark in the flood, and all the rest was drowned." (Ch 6) Later on (Ch 9) there is a real flood and one of the major characters is drowned.
• As Ursula grows into sexuality, she is intrigued by the verse: "The Sons of God saw the daughters of men that they were fair" (Ch 10; quoting the King James Bible version of Genesis 6.2; a verse that is part of the reason given for why God sought to destroy mankind with a flood) and she wonders whether the Sons of God would have found her fair, and who these Sons of God were: "Was not Jesus the only begotten Son? Was not Adam the only man created from God? ... Had God many offspring, besides Adam and besides Jesus, whose origin the children of Adam cannot recognize? And perhaps these children, these Sons of God, had known no expulsion, no ignominy of the fall." (Ch 10) Ursula seems to be trying to come to terms, as children must in adolescence, with the fact that she is a sexual being, despite the apparent proscription of sexuality by the Church, as encapsulated in the Garden of Eden story that recounts that once Adam and Eve had disobeyed God by tasting the fruit of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, they were ashamed of their nudity and made for themselves clothing. 
• This is one of the themes of the novel, that sexual love is spiritual, as shown in the heightened emotions of the following passages:
• “She was sure to come at last, and touch him. Then he burst into flame for her, and lost himself. They looked at each other, a deep laugh at the bottom of their eyes, and he went to take of her again, wholesale, mad to revel in the inexhaustible wealth of her, to bury himself in the depths of her in an inexhaustible exploration, she all the while revelling in that he revelled in her.” (Ch 2) 
• “But hard and fierce she had fastened upon him, cold as the moon and burning as a fierce salt. Till gradually his warm, soft iron yielded, yielded, and she was there fierce, corrosive, seething with his destruction, seething like some cruel, corrosive salt around the last substance of his being, destroying him, destroying him in the kiss. And her soul crystallized with triumph, and his soul dissolved with agony and annihilation. So she held him there, the victim, consumed, annihilated. She had triumphed: he was not anymore.” (Ch 11) And later "She began to caress him to life again. For he was dead.” Ursula has just kissed (yes, it is only a kiss) Anton. But it sounds like they have had sex. And the corollary of sex is that afterwards the man's penis is (usually) limp and must be encouraged to become erect again which is what sounds like is happening in that added line. But Lawrence is, perhaps, adding the religious overlay of the resurrection of Jesus after his death.
• “Darkness cleaving to darkness, she hung close to him, down to the source and core of his kiss, herself covered and enveloped in the warm, fecund flow of his kiss, that traveled over her, flowed over her, covered her, flowed over the last fibre of her, so they were one stream, one dark fecundity, and she clung at the core of him, with her lips holding open the very bottom-most source of him.” (Ch 15)
• When Anna gets pregnant “The blaze of light on her heart was too beautiful and dazzling, from the conception in her womb. She walked glorified, and the sound of the thrushes, of the trains in the valley, of the far-off, faint noises of the town, were her ‘Magnificat’.” (Ch 6) The Magnificat is the from Luke 1.46 - 55; it is a song which the Virgin Mary, newly pregnant with Jesus, sings. Here Anna is identifying herself with Mary and Lawrence seems to be suggesting that the everyday miracle of pregnancy has a spiritual dimension.
• "Gradually it dawned upon Ursula that all the religion she knew was but a particular clothing to a human aspiration. The aspiration was the real thing, - the clothing was a matter almost of national taste or need. The Greeks had a naked Apollo, the Christians a white-robed Christ, the Buddhists a royal prince, the Egyptians their Osiris." (Ch 12)
• The day after her first passionate kiss with Anton, Ursula goes to church and glances at Genesis ("her favourite book") in the Bible: "And God blessed Noah and his sons, and said unto them, Be fruitful and multiply and replenish the earth." (Genesis 9.1) Ursula seems to interpret this as a commandment to have have sex. Lawrence then has Ursula reflect on lines later in the chapter: "And God said, This is the token of the covenant which I make between me and you and every living creature that is with you, for perpetual generations: I do set my bow in the cloud, and it shall be for a token of a covenant between me and the earth. And it shall come to pass, when I bring a cloud over the earth, that the bow shall be seen in the cloud: And I will remember my covenant, which is between me and you and every living creature of all flesh; and the waters shall no more become a flood to destroy all flesh." (Ch 11) This 'bow' is a rainbow and given that this is the title of the book, this must be significant. 
• There are two other mentions of the rainbow. Already Anna, at the end of chapter 6, Ursula being newly born, interprets the rainbow as an arched door, like a new day: "Dawn and sunset were the feet of the rainbow that spanned the day, and she saw the hope, the promise." She is pregnant again and sees herself as that door: "She was a door and a threshold, she herself. Through her another soul was coming" (Ch 6) Then, on the very last page, Ursula has a similar vision. Having dumped her lover and then discovered that she isn't after all, pregnant, she sees a rainbow and interprets it, as Anna did, as God promised in Genesis, as a symbol of hope: "And the rainbow stood on the earth. She knew that the sordid people who crept hard-scaled and separate on the face of the world's corruption were living still, that the rainbow arched in their blood and would quiver to life in their spirit, that they would cast off their horny covering of disintegration, that new, clean, naked bodies would issue to a new germination, to a hew growth, rising in the light and the wind and the clean air of heaven. She saw in the rainbow the earths new architecture, the old, brittle corruption of houses and factories swept away, the world built up in a living fabric of Truth, fitting to the over-arching heaven." Here we have a last remembrance of Zola's novel about mining communities, Germinal, in that word "germination". We have a hint of the flood that swept the corrupt world away. And we have the promise of renewal.

But this sprawling novel also touches on other issues:

Time and again, Lawrence, in part by giving sex such a spiritual charge, highlights the importance of having children over other activities:

• “It was so sweet and satisfying lying there talking desultorily with her. It was sweeter than sunshine, and not so evanescent. It was even irritating the way the church-clock kept on chiming.” (Ch 6) The best things in life, Will thinks, are lying in bed next to one's mate.
• “He did not attach any vital importance to his life in the drafting office, or his life among men. That was just merely the margin to the text.” (Ch 6) Will realises work is not important.
• “He wanted to loom important as master of one of the innumerable domestic craft that make up the great fleet of society. It seemed to her a ridiculous armada of tubs jostling in futility.” (Ch 6) Anna sees having a job as unimportant.
• “Containing birth and death, potential with all the noise and transition of life, the cathedral remained hushed, a great, involved seed, whereof the flower would be radiant life inconceivable, but whose beginning and whose end were a circle of silence. Spanned round with the rainbow, the jewelled gloom folded music upon silence, light upon darkness, fecundity upon death as a seed folds leaf upon leaf and silence upon the root and the flower.” (Ch 7) Even a cathedral is fundamentally about fecundity.
• “The altar was barren, its light gone out. God burned no more in that bush. It was dead matter lying there.” (Ch 7)

There is a scathing critique of the exploitation of those who labour in a mine. This seemed to draw on Germinal, Zola's 1885 novel about a mining community in France; indeed  the word 'Zolaesque' is used. The thesis is that the demands of the mine subvert morals and even shape the men working in it:

• "They believe they must alter themselves to fit the pits and the place, rather than alter the pits and the place to fit themselves." (Ch 12) This reminded me of the thesis in The Time Machine by H G Wells that  humans would evolve into two species: one living lives of ease and happiness on the surface, the other toiling underground.
• “Marriage and home is a little side-show. ... Every man has his own little side-show, but the pit owns every man. The women have what is left.” (Ch 12)
• “Mrs Smith has two sisters who have just changed husbands. ... They're not interested enough to be very immoral - it all amounts to the same thing, moral or immoral - just a question of pit wages. The most moral duke in England makes two hundred thousand a year out of these pits. He keeps the morality end up.” (Ch 12)
• “There was a horrible fascination in it - human bodies and lives subjected in slavery to that symmetric monster of the colliery.” (Ch 12) This reminded me of Chief Bromden in One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest.

More scathing social comment is reserved for the school in which Ursula teaches: “The first great task was to reduce sixty children to one state of mind, or being. This state must be produced automatically, through the will of the teacher, and the will of the whole school authority, imposed upon the will of the children. ... Children will never naturally acquiesce to sitting in a class and submitting to knowledge. They must be compelled by a stronger, wiser will. Against which will they must always strive to revolt.” (Ch 13)

Nor is Ursula impressed by the teaching in her college:

• “The lecturer was a mouth-piece, a priest. As he stood, black gowned, on the rostrum, some strands of the whispering confusion of knowledge that filled the whole place seemed to be singled out and woven together by him, till they became a lecture.” (Ch 15)
• “What was Latin? - So much dry goods of knowledge. What was the Latin class altogether but a sort of second-hand curio shop.” (Ch 15)
• “This was no religious retreat, No seclusion of pure learning. It was a little apprentice-shop where one was further equipped for making money. The college was a little, slovenly laboratory for the factory.” (Ch 15) Views diametrically against those of Mrs Gaskell in North and South in which a factory owner seeks tuition in the classics to culture himself and to become a gentleman.
• Her disillusion with learning culminates in a brilliant metaphor in which Lawrence inverts Plato's Allegory of the Cave: “She could see the glimmer of dark movement just out of the range, she saw the eyes of the wild beast gleaming from the darkness, watching the vanity of the camp fire and the sleepers; she felt the strange, foolish vanity of the camp, which said ‘Beyond our light and our order there is nothing’, turning their faces always inward towards the sinking fire of illuminating consciousness ... ignoring always the vast darkness that wheeled round about, with half-revealed shapes lurking on the edge. Yea, and no man dared even throw a firebrand Into the darkness. For if he did he was jeered to death by the others who cried, ‘Fool, antisocial knave, why would you disturb us with bogeys? There is no darkness. We move and live and have our being within the light, and unto us is given the eternal light of knowledge.” (Ch 15)

There is a lesbian affair between Ursula and one of her teachers but there's also a hint of male homosexuality when Tom Brangwen meets Winifred Inger who has been having a lesbian affair with Ursula. He looks at her and “Immediately, he knew they were akin.” This suggests that he's gay and so’s she. And that's why they get married.

So that's the content; what about the style. The prose is remarkable for its passion. This sort of stuff could easily be mocked, as Stella Gibbons did in Cold Comfort Farm, but Lawrence's passion has depth and is from the heart. 

• “In autumn the partridges whirred up, birds in flocks blue like spray across the fallow, rooks appeared on the grey, watery heavens, and flew cawing into the winter. Then the men sat by the fire in the house where the women moved about with surety, and the limbs and the body of the men were impregnated with the day, cattle and earth and vegetation and the sky, the men sat by the fire and their brains were inert, as their blood flowed heavy with the accumulation from the living day.” (Ch 1) 
• “They were such strangers, they must forever be such strangers, that his passion was a clanging torment to him. Such intimacy of embrace, and such utter foreignness of contact! It was unbearable. He could not bear to be near her, and know the utter foreignness between them, know how entirely they were strangers to each other.” (Ch 1) He makes use of repetition to emphasise, almost to pound his words into the reader’s brain. This occurs time and again, and reminded me of the repetitions in the Bible. 

Selected quotes:

• “She was like one walking in the Underworld, where the shades throng intelligibly but have no connection with one.” (Ch 2)
• “His heart heavy as the sudden earth.” (Ch 2)
• “She looked at him, and oh, the weariness to her of the effort to understand another language, the weariness of hearing him.” (Ch 2)
• “How did she say he was old. He walked on in the rain, sweating with pain, with the horror of being old, with the agony of having to relinquish what was life to him.” (Ch 4)
• “Was his life nothing? Had he nothing to show, no work? He did not count his work, anybody could have done it. What had he known, but the long, marital embrace with his wife! curious, that this was what his life amounted to! At any rate, it was something, it was eternal.” (Ch 4)
• “There was no peace, however old one grew! One was never right, never decent, never master of oneself.” (Ch 4)
• “He did not count the days. but like a man who journeys in a ship, he was suspended till the coming to port.” (Ch 4)
• “Brangwen was staring away at the burning blue window at the back of the altar, and wondering vaguely, with pain, if he ever should get old, if he ever should feel arrived and established.” (Ch 5)
• “She had thought him just the bright reflex of herself. As the weeks and months went by she realized that he was a dark opposite to her.” (Ch 6)
• “He and she were not one. His heat was not always to suffuse her, suffuse her, through her mind and her individuality, till she was of one heat with him, till she had not heard own self apart. She wanted her own life. He seemed to lap her and suffuse her with his being, his hot life, till she did not know whether she were herself, or whether she were another creature.” (Ch 7)
• “He thought of the ruins of the Grecian worship, and it seemed a temple was never perfectly a temple, till it was ruined and mixed up with the winds and the sky and the herbs.” (Ch 7)
• “She was the day-time, the daylight, he was the shadow; put aside, but in the darkness potent with an overwhelming voluptuousness." (Ch 8)
• “It was when they brought him to her house dead and in his wet clothes, his wet, sodden clothes, fully dressed as though he came from market, yet all sudden and inert, that the shock really broke into her and she was terrified. A big, soaked, inert heap, he was, who had been to her the image of power and strong life.” (Ch 9)
• “As Ursula passed from girlhood towards womanhood, gradually the cloud of self-responsibility gathered upon her. She became aware of herself, that she was a separate entity in the midst of an unseparated obscurity, that she must go somewhere, she must become something.” (Ch 11)
• “A fearless-seeming clean type of modern girl whose very independence betrays her sorrow.” (Ch 12)
• “She was brought to the conclusion that the human desire is the criterion of all truth and all good.” (Ch 12)
• “And yet - and yet - one's kite will rise on the wind as far as ever one has string to let it go.” (Ch 14)
• “The great notice-board with its fluttering papers seemed to slam away all sense of retreat and mystery from the far wall.” (Ch 15)
• “She had the ash of disillusion gritting under her teeth.” (Ch 15)
• “What did it mean, Ursula Brangwen? She did not know what she was. Only she was full of rejection, of refusal. Always, always she was spitting out of her mouth the ash and grit of disillusion, a falsity. She could only stiffen in rejection, in rejection. She seemed always negative in her action.” (Ch 15)
• “But his eyes were quite still, like a washed sky after rain, full of a wan light, and quite steady, almost ghost-like.” (Ch 15)
• “I could love a hundred men, one after the other. ... Why should I not go on, and love all the types I fancy, one after another, if love is an end in itself?” (Ch 15)

Influences

It feels like a Victorian novel, such as The Way of All Flesh by Samuel Butler which was published in 1903. There's also a feel of the social novels of H G Wells, such as Love and Mr Lewisham (1900), Kipps (1905), and The History of Mr Polly (1910). The concept that humans might evolve as a result of industrialisation is mentioned; this was first explored by H G Wells in The Time Machine (1895). There's also a mention of the Invisible Man by H G Wells: “She was reminded of the Invisible Man, who was a piece of darkness made visible only by his clothes.” (Ch 15) And the use of the term "Zolaesque" in the context of a mining village, is presumably a reference to Zola's Germinal (1885).

In the run up to 1915, H G Wells and Arnold Bennett (Anna of the Five Towns) had started to prove that working class people could be novelists. The influence of Thomas Hardy might have given Lawrence the confidence to use dialect in his fiction.

Aftermath

The Rainbow was prosecuted for obscenity, seized and destroyed; it disappeared from the (English) market for 16 years. You can understand the objections of the moralists of the time. Not only does it treat sex as a natural and, indeed, spiritual part of everyday experiences, but it also includes passages an orthodox Christian might consider blasphemous, and it contains an episode of lesbian love. This was thirteen years before Radclyffe Hall's novel The Well of Loneliness celebrated sapphism and was successfully prosecuted for obscenity. Perhaps 'The Rainbow' set a precedent.

Notes:

The Pillens (Phillips) family, school pupils with Ursula, and teacher Miss Inger, are mentioned in Lawrence's debut novel, Sons and Lovers

September 2026; 496 pages
First published by Methuen in 1915
My Penguin paperback was issued in 1985

This review was written by

the author of Bally and Bro, Motherdarling 

and The Kids of God

Other novels by D H Lawrence include:

• The White Peacock (1911)
• The Trespasser (1912)
• Sons and Lovers (1913)
• The Rainbow (1915)
• Women in Love (1920)
• The Lost Girl (1920)
• Aaron's Rod (1922)
• Kangaroo (1923)
• The Plumed Serpent (1926)
• Lady Chatterley's Lover (1928)
• The Escaped Cock (1929), republished as The Man Who Died

Collection of short stories: 

• England, My England